This story first appeared in Anna Fifield’s Between Giants newsletter and is re-published with permission
Comment: If the Auckland mayor were a Chinese politician, he’d quickly find himself detained – or worse – for uttering the kind of things he says in NZ about the NZ government. That’s the beauty of democracy: we are free to speak critically and to hold power to account.
So I was sitting at my computer yesterday pondering a post about Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown’s comments to Stuff after he returned from a trip to China. He said: China’s “centrally managed capitalism” was “working” as opposed to the “unfathomable” election we just had and the “non-working government” in the United States.
Among his choicest quotes:
“Democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else, really. I mean, the Chinese have got centrally managed capitalism. We don’t have capitalism. America doesn’t have capitalism. China has capitalism. Capitalism where you have brutal competition and they allow you to fail.”
While in China, a state media interviewer asked Brown how New Zealand reconciled its membership in the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing group — with the United States, United Kingdom, Canada and Australia — with the fact that China is by far its largest trading partner. Brown responded that New Zealand should leave the Five Eyes network by “selling our seat to Japan”. (By the way, that’s not a thing.)
So I was gathering my thoughts and wondering whether I could publicly call Brown an “ignorant muppet”. Then the Trump-appointed ambassador to Aotearoa came out with a social media post that made my language look positively diplomatic:
Novelly then doubled down with a punchy interview with Radio New Zealand (in which Lisa Owen again shows why she’s The Boss): US Ambassador to NZ lashes out at Auckland mayor.
The ambassador’s remarks about the importance of a free press made me laugh, given that Donald Trump has excluded journalists from the White House and sued media outlets into submission.
But his remarks about Brown were apposite, if sharply worded.
Brown’s comments prove him to be acting as a “useful idiot” for China. It’s a term that originated during the Soviet era to describe westerners who swallowed – and spouted – communist propaganda. The fact they were outsiders from non-communist countries gave credence and lent legitimacy to the lies and exaggerations of the state’s narrative.
The phrase is often attributed to Vladimir Lenin, who’s reported to have said “deaf, dumb, and blind” non-communist sympathisers helped the Soviet cause. The most famous “useful idiot” of the Soviet era was Walter Duranty, who regurgitated Kremlin propaganda for The New York Times in the 1920s and 30s.
I’ve met plenty of these useful idiots during my years of reporting, from the Belgians I met in North Korea who praised the free healthcare (never mind that North Korean hospitals are so poorly resourced they don’t even have paracetamol) and the fellow travellers in China who go on state television to praise the communist system.
See also: The former Prince Andrew and Tucker Carlson.
There’s been a particular proliferation of this in the YouTube age, as China has invited western “influencers” (and a whole lot of nobodies) to show the “real story” of China.
These are usually people with no knowledge of China or the Chinese language, but there are also people working in the state media who are happy to spread China’s propaganda. One of them is Andy Boreham, a New Zealander working for a Chinese state media outlet in Shanghai (read Sam Sachdeva’s excellent piece from a few years ago about him).
People including Boreham travel to places like Xinjiang and say the western media has been telling lies about human rights abuses there — despite the fact they’ve been well documented by the United Nations and international journalists, including in forensically reported stories that have won the Pulitzer Prize.
Further proof that Boreham’s messages align nicely with the Chinese Communist Party’s version of events: The Chinese embassy in Wellington recently put on a screening of Boreham’s video about his trip to Tibet (in which he used the Chinese name for that annexed region).
Piers Fuller wrote about this for The Post (paywalled): My evening attending a CPC propaganda screening about Tibet/Xizang.
Anyway, back to Brown. There are the people who get paid to do China’s bidding, then there are those who do it willingly. They go to China and drink the Kool-Aid: Yes, China has made extraordinary economic and technological advances in the past few decades. The buildings are impressive, the trains are fast, the robots are fun. China has built an unassailable lead in many of the technologies of the future — including solar panels, wind turbines and batteries — and BYD has displaced Tesla as the world’s biggest electric car maker.
Along the way, some 800 million Chinese people have worked their way out of poverty.
All of this is genuinely impressive and should absolutely be acknowledged. But to praise this without context – and to suggest it is a sign of a superior system – is boneheaded.
China has achieved much of its gains through terrible working conditions – including child labour and forced internal migration. In 2020 I went to a Nike factory near Qingdao where groups of young, mostly Uyghur Muslims had been sent to work some 4000 km from home – partly to break their cultural and familial bonds as part of Beijing’s assimilation programme.
And Chinese people have no say in how their society is run. There is no longer any real avenue for dissent or appeal in China. There are no longer any independent media outlets – Reporters Without Borders calls China the world’s “largest prison for journalists” – and social media is highly censored. People who try to post anything remotely critical might get a visit from their local police.
People’s homes have been demolished to make way for factories and roads. The conviction rate in Chinese courts is more than 99 percent. Youth unemployment skyrocketing? Beijing simply stopped publishing the figures. Problem solved.
So when people with influence in their country, like Brown, as mayor of New Zealand’s biggest city, willingly talk about all the pros without acknowledging any of the cons? Well, that’s the kind of messaging Beijing can’t buy.