Independent review ordered into surgery carried out by NHS Grampian

Scottish Labour’s health spokeswoman, Jackie Baillie, said the review was “welcome”, adding that a similar situation “must never happen ever again”.

She said: “Were it not for the bravery of Dr Habib in this week speaking out, we may never have known just how far this went.

“Grieving families who lost loved ones in the care of NHS Grampian deserve the full truth of what happened at the health board, including who knew what was going on, when they knew, and why it has taken this long for these concerns to come to light.”

Yi-pei Chou Turvey, Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP for north east Scotland, said the wait for answers for the families of affected patients had been “excruciating”.

She added: “SNP ministers ought to have been battering down the door of NHS Grampian after receiving multiple warnings from Dr Habib and a report uncovering 19 avoidable deaths.

“This independent review must quickly and thoroughly establish why John Swinney, Humza Yousaf and successive health secretaries failed to grasp what was going on and intervene.”

Scottish Conservative health spokesman Miles Briggs said the review should not be used as a “vehicle to shirk responsibility”.

“This review must determine exactly what information reached Scottish ministers and NHS Grampian executives and what action was taken,” he said.

“For patients and their families, the review must follow the evidence wherever it leads and ensure full accountability at every level.”