Good morning. Everyone sort of agrees it’s “wrong.” That’s what one of Russell Brand’s accusers, Mia Latter, said when she waived her right to anonymity and spoke publicly about her alleged sexual relationship with the now convicted rapist, when he was 30, and she was just 16.
And yet a sexual relationship between a 16-year-old and a 30-year-old is not, in itself, illegal. The UK, like many other countries, sets 16 as the age of consent, not 18. Campaigners like Latter say this leaves the door open for exploitative relationships between children and adults; others warn that changing the laws around consent could criminalise teenagers in relationships with people close to their age.
Now, there’s a growing chorus of calls for a staggered age of consent. For today’s First Edition, I spoke to Layla Stone, co-founder of the campaign group Close the Consent Gap, about what that might look like, and whether it could actually protect young people. That’s after the headlines.
Five big stories
-
UK | A senior doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby and who was held up by prosecutors as a pre-eminent expert was barred from treating patients during the trial over fears he posed a risk to their safety.
-
Energy | Energy bills across Great Britain are predicted to reach £2,166 a year for the typical household from January as the impact of the Middle East conflict piles pressure on the government to offer more support to hard-hit households.
-
Israel | Israel has postponed issuing contracts for the construction of a large settlement on the West Bank seen as likely to render a two-state solution unviable, days after the UK imposed sanctions against building firms operating in the area.
-
Brexit | The EU will shut the door to discussions with Andy Burnham about the UK’s longer-term relationship with the bloc until the government has decided whether it wants to proceed with reversing Brexit, diplomats have said.
-
Myanmar | Fears are growing that the US could impose sanctions on judges at the international court of justice, including this year’s Nobel peace prize winner, Navi Pillay, if the court rules on Thursday that the Myanmar government committed genocide against the Rohingya.
In depth: Do 19- and 20-year-olds count as teenagers?
Mia Latter was out shopping when she first met the then cultural juggernaut Russell Brand, who took her number and later asked her out on a date. She says that Brand had asked her to keep their relationship a secret from her school friends, though he referred to her as “the child” in front of his own. Latter alleges that their three-month relationship ended with Russell Brand orally raping her – allegations which Brand denies, and are being investigated by police.
Over the last few weeks, the world’s eyes have been fixed first on Brand’s conviction and sentencing to a 10 and a half year prison sentence for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault; and then on allegations about predatory behaviour towards teenage girls by the comedian and author David Walliams.
Walliams also disputes the claims against him, denying any wrongdoing and insisting that he has not broken the law. And, as it stands, an adult having sex with a teenager isn’t necessarily illegal. But this grey area, where an age gap is enough to make us feel icky, but where we refuse to draw a legal line, is what has allowed the campaign to introduce a staggered age of consent in the UK to gain ground.
“Russell Brand admitted to [US Presenter] Megyn Kelly that he had a relationship with a 16-year-old when he was 30.” In that interview, Brand described his behaviour as “Awful … but lawful.”.
“That just made me go, ‘Well sod this – why is it not unlawful? It absolutely has to be,’” says Stone.
Pat McFadden, the Labour work and pensions secretary, has said the government will consider changing the age of consent laws in England and Wales, cautioning that there are many complexities to work through.
How would it work?
Close the Consent Gap launched in April 2026, founded by a group of child specialists, including social workers, psychologists and lawyers. The group highlights that while 16-year-olds in the UK cannot marry (which became illegal for under-18s in 2023), gamble or buy alcohol, they can consent to sex with a much older person. (They can, however, pay taxes and join the armed forces.)
Close the Consent Gap is calling for a staggered age of consent, under which it would be an offence for someone to have sex with a 16- or 17-year-old if they are more than three years older. This would mean a 16-year-old could legally have a relationship with someone aged up to 19, but not with someone aged 20 or over.
This, Stone argues, would avoid punishing teenagers navigating sexual experiences with people in their peer groups, while protecting them from significant power imbalances.
“Most 16-year-olds are still in education, living with parents or in the care of a local authority. Whereas many 20-year-olds are graduating, and may well be in full-time employment, or moving out to flat-shares,” she says. “We feel there is a real life shift that happens in those four years.”
As a social worker, Stone has seen how older predators can deliberately “exploit that two-year age gap before 16-year-olds become adults.” She believes the change to the law would bring it into line with other legislation: “If someone is in possession of an indecent image of a 16 or 17-year-old, they are liable to become a sex offender. So why not if they are actually having sex with them?”
Staggered ages of consent and close-in-age exemptions exist elsewhere in the world. In Canada, the legal age of consent is 16. There are also exceptions for sexual activity involving younger teenagers: 12- and 13-year-olds can consent to activity with someone less than two years older, while 14- and 15-year-olds can consent to activity with someone less than five years older. In the US, the law varies by state, with Florida teenagers aged 16 or 17 able to consent to sex with someone under 24 in some circumstances, and other US states having clearcut cut-off lines of three years. Teenagers in these countries are still protected from exploitation by other parts of the law.
The complexities
Some are concerned that introducing a staggered age of consent may criminalise minors, and that new consent laws could ultimately stop younger teenagers from seeking out sexual health advice and support.
Our columnist Gaby Hinsliff laid out what that could look like in real terms this week, pointing out that under this proposed law, a 19-year-old might end up on a sex offender register for having a sexual relationship with a 16-year-old. And a complaint might not come from the teenager involved – but a disapproving adult in their lives.
There’s no clear evidence of more young people being criminalised in countries with a staggered age of consent. But edge cases do exist, where 19 and 20-year-olds are handed lengthy sentences for sexual relationships with people in their peer groups where a staggered age of consent exists. So if you’re wondering where you stand on a possible law change, you may want to ask yourself: do 19- and 20-year-olds count as teenagers, for you?
Ultimately, Stone says we have to draw a line somewhere. “The same logic can be used to say we are criminalising 16-year-olds for having sex with 14-year-olds. But we decided that should be illegal,” she says.
What other options are there?
Stone believes that today, 16-year-olds seem a lot younger. The requirement to stay in education or training until age 18, which came into force in 2015, means that many now still live at home with their parents, where before it was more common for them to be in full-time work or live out of the family home.
But the same surely applies to 21-year-olds today – who this law would apply to – and who are increasingly living at home well into early adulthood.
Stone acknowledges these are grey areas that the law could be adapted to account for.
“A sensible thing would be to have sentencing guidelines that say if you’re 10 years older, then you’re liable to a much harsher punishment than someone who’s, say, three years older,” she says. But this raises a broader question: is the age of consent too blunt an instrument to take account for the nuances of autonomy and maturity, which vary from person to person?
Dr Kate Greasley, associate professor of law at Oxford University has spent a lot of time studying the ethics of consent in a post #Me Too era, and points out that there’s a common temptation to fold the whole of what could be wrong with a sexual interaction under the law of consent.
“That can back people into tight corners. Outside age gaps, sexual activity can still be exploitative, degrading, dehumanising, one-sided, or just plain bad, all while being consensual,” she says. “Feminists have highlighted this for a long time: you obscure a lot of problems by [with] the suggestion that as long as something is consensual it’s fine.”
What if, instead, Greasley asks: “Well, it was consented to, it was freely chosen, but it was still exploitative?”
This opens up the possible legal frameworks that could be drawn. For example, should existing laws around grooming and exploitation have stronger provisions to protect 16- and 17-year-olds, recognising that they can be groomed even when they are legally capable of consent?
after newsletter promotion
Of course, that’s a much trickier road to go down – one that has no clear line in the sand around what sort of age gap constitutes a power imbalance. But no one said there would be easy answers.
What else we’ve been reading
-
I love hearing what our readers have to say about, well, anything! But I was especially intrigued to see what they’d make of Robert Pattinson as the new James Bond. Responses ran the gamut from “a dream come true” to “the worst decision in all of cinema history”. Shots fired. Lucinda Everett, newsletters team
-
Genuinely impressive, this: Bangladeshi bloke Abdul Goni Gazi saves humans and tigers from butchering the other with the help of a wooden stick. Rather him than me. Michael Segalov, newsletters team
-
Alice Speri is excellent on the Democrat’s new goal after the midterms blue tsunami: convince Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to run for president. Lucinda
-
Workers at Rockstar, the company behind Grand Theft Auto, are fighting for trade union recognition. Nestor Uriarte is one of them – and his column is excellent. Michael
-
I’ve found our This is Climate Breakdown series, which explores the real impacts of the climate crisis on people, extremely moving and exceptionally important. The latest is Guadalupe Cobos Pacheco’s story about how sea encroachment destroyed the Mexican fishing village she called home. Lucinda
Sport
Football | Chelsea lacked spark in attack against Paris Saint-Germain but Veerle Buurman sealed a 1-0 win to send them top of the Women’s Champions League table
Cricket | Cameron Bancroft has shattered Cricket Australia’s attempts to draw a line under the sandpaper scandal by claiming that all players and coaches on the infamous tour of South Africa knew about a plot to tamper with the ball.
Tennis | Alexander Zverev was officially notified of a lawsuit filed by his former partner during the middle of the season-ending ATP Finals on Wednesday.
The front pages
“Doctor who helped convict Letby was barred from treating patients”, is the Guardian’s front page today.
The Times has “PM cabinet ally accused over oilfield rejection”, the Mail writes “Kemi: PM’s Brexit surrender is ‘worst of both worlds’”, the i Paper says “Under-30s set to get EU work and study visas by 2028 under new Brexit deal”. The FT leads on “Tariff spat with Brussels jeopardises hopes for ‘made in Europe’ rewards”. The Mirror has “£433 energy bills hike”, and Metro’s take is “Boiling point”.
The Telegraph leads on an interview with Prince Harry, writing “I’d rejoin Army to fight Russia”. The Sun splashes on Anthony Joshua with “I have a new baby girl.. she’s a blessing”.
The Latest
How Ukraine landed a blow to Putin’s prized Crimean bridge
Volodymyr Zelenskyy has hailed an ‘unprecedented operation’ to severely damage a critical bridge between Russia and occupied Crimea. The Kerch bridge was built by Russia after its illegal annexation of the Crimean peninsula in 2014, and the attack this week marks a significant blow to Vladimir Putin’s war efforts just before his meeting with the US and Chinese presidents. With Ukraine able to secure a significant military victory, have we reached a turning point in the conflict? Lucy Hough speaks to senior international correspondent Luke Harding and the author of Betrayal: Trump, Putin and the New Age of Conquest.
Cartoon of the day | Ella Baron
The Upside
A bit of good news to remind you that the world’s not all bad
If you’re looking to refresh your Christmas decoration stash this year from the usual red, greens and gold, we have a tip for you: it’s important that you know kitsch, gaudy and otherwise deliberately tacky Christmas decorations are in vogue.
Fortunately, for the Filter, Lily Smith has rounded up 26 of the best ones out there, from a beaded martini to some felt cheeses to a … pigeon dressed as a Beefeater?
Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, sent to you every Sunday
Bored at work?
And finally, the Guardian’s puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day – with plenty more on the Guardian’s Puzzles app for iOS and Android. Until tomorrow.